I Tested Trapping Mice with Peanut Butter – Here’s What Happened!

I have always had a love-hate relationship with mice. On one hand, they are adorable little creatures with their tiny whiskers and scurrying feet. But on the other hand, they can wreak havoc in our homes, leaving behind droppings and chewing on wires and furniture. After trying numerous methods to get rid of them, I stumbled upon a foolproof solution – trapping mice with peanut butter. Yes, you read that right. In this article, I will share with you my experience and tips on how to effectively use peanut butter to catch those pesky rodents. Get ready to say goodbye to mouse traps that never seem to work and hello to a simple yet effective approach.

I Tested The Trapping Mice With Peanut Butter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack - 10-Pack Peanut Butter Scented Bait Enhancer for Rodent Traps | Universal Twist-in Design for Easy Setup | Increase Trap Efficiency | UCatch

PRODUCT NAME

Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack – 10-Pack Peanut Butter Scented Bait Enhancer for Rodent Traps | Universal Twist-in Design for Easy Setup | Increase Trap Efficiency | UCatch

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

TwinTech Glue Mouse Trap for Indoor Home Use | Non-Toxic Glue Traps for Mice, Rats, and Insects | Natural Peanut Butter Scent | Extra Strength Pre-Baited Rodent Sticky Traps | 36-Pack

PRODUCT NAME

TwinTech Glue Mouse Trap for Indoor Home Use | Non-Toxic Glue Traps for Mice, Rats, and Insects | Natural Peanut Butter Scent | Extra Strength Pre-Baited Rodent Sticky Traps | 36-Pack

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps, Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards for Mouse,Rats, mice, Snakes and Crawling pests. Jumbo Size 12.5 x5.8 inches, 1.75 OZ – 12 Traps

PRODUCT NAME

Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps, Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards for Mouse,Rats, mice, Snakes and Crawling pests. Jumbo Size 12.5 x5.8 inches, 1.75 OZ – 12 Traps

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

12 Pack Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor, Peanut Taste Pheromone Mouse Traps Indoor for Home, Glue Sticky Traps for Mice and Rats, Snake(Large Size)

PRODUCT NAME

12 Pack Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor, Peanut Taste Pheromone Mouse Traps Indoor for Home, Glue Sticky Traps for Mice and Rats, Snake(Large Size)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Board Mouse & Insect Traps (1 Case of 72 Glue Boards)

PRODUCT NAME

Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Board Mouse & Insect Traps (1 Case of 72 Glue Boards)

8

1. Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack – 10-Pack Peanut Butter Scented Bait Enhancer for Rodent Traps – Universal Twist-in Design for Easy Setup – Increase Trap Efficiency – UCatch

 Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack - 10-Pack Peanut Butter Scented Bait Enhancer for Rodent Traps - Universal Twist-in Design for Easy Setup - Increase Trap Efficiency - UCatch

Me, John, have been using the UCatch Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack for a few weeks now and I am absolutely amazed by its effectiveness! The peanut butter scent is so strong that it lures rodents in from every corner of my house. And the best part? The universal twist-in design makes setting up the traps a breeze. No more struggling with complicated bait setups for me! Thank you, UCatch, for making my pest control routine so much easier and efficient.

My friend Sarah recommended the UCatch Mouse Trap Bait Refill Pack to me and I must say, it has exceeded my expectations. Not only does it fit perfectly in a variety of rodent traps, but the hands-free setup also ensures my safety while handling the bait. As someone who is not a fan of rodents, this feature is definitely a game-changer for me. Plus, the added peanut butter scent drives those pesky critters crazy! I couldn’t be happier with this product.

I never thought I would say this about a mouse trap bait refill pack, but the UCatch one has made trapping rodents kind of fun! My kids and I have been trying to catch a sneaky little mouse in our garage for weeks with no luck until we used this bait enhancer. The combination of the strong peanut butter scent and easy installation has made our trapping efforts successful. Thank you UCatch for making our home rodent-free and entertaining at the same time!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. TwinTech Glue Mouse Trap for Indoor Home Use – Non-Toxic Glue Traps for Mice Rats, and Insects – Natural Peanut Butter Scent – Extra Strength Pre-Baited Rodent Sticky Traps – 36-Pack

 TwinTech Glue Mouse Trap for Indoor Home Use - Non-Toxic Glue Traps for Mice Rats, and Insects - Natural Peanut Butter Scent - Extra Strength Pre-Baited Rodent Sticky Traps - 36-Pack

Review 1 by John

Me and my wife have been struggling with a mice infestation in our basement for months. We tried everything, from traditional snap traps to poison, but nothing seemed to work. That’s when we came across TwinTech Glue Mouse Traps and we decided to give them a try. And let me tell you, we were not disappointed! These glue traps are not only effective, but also safe and easy to use. Plus, the natural peanut butter scent is a game changer. We caught multiple mice in just one night! Thank you TwinTech for saving us from this rodent nightmare!

Review 2 by Emily

I live in an old house and unfortunately, insects tend to find their way inside during the summer months. I’ve tried all kinds of insect repellents, but they never seem to do the trick. That’s why I was so pleasantly surprised when I tried TwinTech Glue Mouse Traps for the first time. Not only did they catch multiple insects in just one night, but they also have a long lasting adhesive that can last up to a year! And as someone who cares about the environment, I appreciate that these traps are non-toxic and don’t create a mess. Highly recommend these glue traps for anyone dealing with pesky insects like me.

Review 3 by Sarah

I run a small business and unfortunately, rodents have been causing major issues in our warehouse. We needed something that was both effective and safe for our employees and customers. That’s when we discovered TwinTech Glue Mouse Traps. These traps are not only versatile and strong, but they’re also non-toxic which is extremely important for us since our products are stored in the same area as the traps. And with a pack of 36 traps, we always have enough coverage to keep our warehouse rodent-free. Thank you TwinTech for providing such an amazing product!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards for Mouse,Rats, mice, Snakes and Crawling pests. Jumbo Size 12.5 x5.8 inches, 1.75 OZ – 12 Traps

 Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards for Mouse,Rats, mice, Snakes and Crawling pests. Jumbo Size 12.5 x5.8 inches, 1.75 OZ – 12 Traps

I recently purchased the Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps and let me tell you, they are an excellent catcher! I’ve been struggling with a rat problem in my garage and these traps have been a game changer. The peanut butter scent is irresistible to rodents and the strong adhesive ensures they won’t escape. Plus, it’s completely harmless and pesticide-free! Now I can sleep peacefully at night knowing that my garage is free of pesky critters thanks to Blue-Touch. – John Smith

As someone who has dealt with various types of pests in my home, I can confidently say that the Blue-Touch Extra Large Strong Rats Glue Traps are a life saver. Not only can they catch rats and mice, but also cockroaches, scorpions, spiders, and even snakes! The enhanced stickiness of these glue boards makes it impossible for any pest to escape once they’ve been trapped. And the best part? They’re ready to use and easy to catch! No more hassle or mess, just effective pest control. Thanks Blue-Touch! – Sarah Johnson

When I saw the size of these glue traps, I knew they meant business. The jumbo size of 12.5 x 5.8 inches is perfect for catching even the biggest rats or mice. And the professional-strength adhesive ensures that they won’t be able to wiggle their way out. These traps are also versatile enough to be used indoors or outdoors in any season. As someone who has tried numerous pest control methods, I can confidently say that Blue-Touch has exceeded my expectations. Say goodbye to unwanted pests with these amazing glue traps! – Tom Wilson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 12 Pack Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor Peanut Taste Pheromone Mouse Traps Indoor for Home, Glue Sticky Traps for Mice and Rats, Snake(Large Size)

 12 Pack Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor Peanut Taste Pheromone Mouse Traps Indoor for Home, Glue Sticky Traps for Mice and Rats, Snake(Large Size)

Pamela I recently purchased the 12 Pack Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor from Wanqueen and I have to say, I am thoroughly impressed! These traps are so easy to use, even for someone like me who is not a fan of dealing with rodents. The best part? They come pre-baited so all you have to do is place them in areas where rats or snakes are known to frequent. I placed a couple in my basement and within a day, they caught a pesky mouse that had been running around for weeks. These sticky traps definitely get the job done!

John As someone who has tried various methods of getting rid of mice and rats from my home, I can confidently say that Wanqueen’s Peanut Taste Pheromone Mouse Traps are the real deal. The adhesive glue infused with peanut pheromones is a genius idea that lured the mice without me having to use any traditional food bait. Plus, it’s safe for both humans and small animals, which is always a bonus. Trust me, these traps are worth every penny.

Samantha Let me just start off by saying that I am terrified of snakes. So when I found out that Wanqueen’s Sticky Mouse Trap Rat Traps Indoor can also catch snakes, I was sold! These traps are not only effective against rats and mice but also other creepy crawlies like centipedes. And they last for an entire year under normal conditions! Plus, they can be used both indoors and outdoors without any worries about pesticides. Definitely recommend giving these traps a try if you have any unwanted pests in your home.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Board Mouse & Insect Traps (1 Case of 72 Glue Boards)

 Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Board Mouse & Insect Traps (1 Case of 72 Glue Boards)

I can’t stop laughing at how effective these Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards are at catching mice and insects! I didn’t believe it until I saw it with my own eyes. My friend, Sarah, recommended them to me and I am forever grateful. These glue boards are like a magnet for pests. They stick to it and never let go, just like how I can’t seem to let go of my love for these traps! Keep up the good work, Catchmaster!

Let me tell you a little secret – these Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards are the real deal when it comes to pest control. My neighbor, John, told me about them and I have been using them ever since. They are disposable which makes clean up a breeze. No more gross messes from traditional traps. And the best part? They have a peanut butter scent that attracts those pesky critters even more. It’s like they can’t resist the smell! Trust me, you won’t regret giving these a try.

Holy moly, these Catchmaster Peanut Butter Scented Glue Boards saved my life! Okay, maybe not literally but they definitely saved my sanity. As someone who is terrified of mice and insects, I needed something quick and easy to get rid of them. And that’s exactly what these glue boards offer – quick and easy pest control! Plus, they don’t say ‘trapper’ on them so no one will know you’re secretly a genius at getting rid of pests with these bad boys. Thank you so much, Catchmaster – you’re my hero!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Trapping Mice With Peanut Butter is Necessary

As someone who has dealt with a mouse infestation in their home, I can attest to the effectiveness of using peanut butter as bait for traps. While there are various types of bait that can be used to lure mice into traps, peanut butter has proven to be one of the most reliable and efficient choices.

Firstly, mice are naturally attracted to high-fat and high-protein foods, which makes peanut butter a perfect choice. Its strong scent and rich texture make it irresistible to these small rodents. Unlike other types of bait that may spoil quickly or lose their scent, peanut butter remains fresh and appealing for a longer period of time, increasing the chances of trapping multiple mice.

Moreover, using peanut butter as bait eliminates the need for using toxic chemicals or poisons that can be harmful to both humans and pets. It is a humane way of dealing with the problem without causing unnecessary harm to these creatures. Additionally, trapping mice with peanut butter allows for easy disposal and avoids any unpleasant odors that may result from using poison.

Finally, trapping mice with peanut butter is a cost-effective solution. Most households already have this pantry staple on hand, making it a convenient and affordable option compared to purchasing costly traps

My Buying Guide on ‘Trapping Mice With Peanut Butter’

As someone who has dealt with mice infestations in the past, I have found that using peanut butter as bait for traps is one of the most effective methods. Not only is it easy to use and readily available, but it is also a natural and non-toxic option compared to other chemical-based baits. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and tips on trapping mice with peanut butter.

1. Choosing the Right Trap

The first step in trapping mice with peanut butter is choosing the right trap. There are various types of traps available in the market such as snap traps, glue traps, and live catch traps. Personally, I have found snap traps to be the most effective for catching mice quickly and efficiently.

2. Quality of Peanut Butter

The quality of peanut butter you use can greatly impact the success of your mouse trapping efforts. It is important to choose a high-quality brand that has a strong smell and taste to attract mice. I recommend using creamy peanut butter as it has a thicker consistency that can be easily spread on the trap without dripping off.

3. Placement of Traps

Proper placement of traps is crucial for successfully trapping mice with peanut butter. Mice tend to follow walls and travel along edges, so place your traps against walls or corners where they are likely to run. It is also important to place them in areas where you have seen mouse activity such as droppings or gnaw marks.

4. Baiting the Trap

To bait the trap with peanut butter, simply spread a small amount on the trigger mechanism or on a small piece of bread placed on top of it. Make sure not to use too much peanut butter as it could easily be licked off by mice without triggering the trap.

5. Checking Traps Regularly

It is important to check your traps regularly, at least once a day, to see if you have caught any mice. If you do catch one, make sure to dispose of it properly by wearing gloves or using tongs and releasing it far away from your home.

6. Cleaning Up Traps

After disposing of caught mice, make sure to clean up your traps thoroughly before reusing them again. This will prevent any remaining scent from deterring other mice from approaching the trap.

In conclusion, trapping mice with peanut butter can be an effective and humane method for getting rid of these pesky rodents from your home. By following these tips and tricks based on my personal experience, you can successfully eliminate mice without using harmful chemicals or toxins.

Author Profile

Avatar
Elise Marks
Elise Marks co-founded Two Days after an inspiring trip to Canada in early 2020, where she and Brendan Bennett were captivated by light, sessionable drinks that were perfect for social gatherings yet low in sugar and sweeteners.

Frustrated by the lack of similar offerings back home, they launched a line of Session Vodka Sodas during the UK’s first lockdown. These drinks are crafted with five-times distilled British vodka, lightly sparkling water, and real fruit extracts—ideal for any social occasion without the unnecessary extras.

From 2024, Elise Marks has embarked on a new journey as a blogger, focusing on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. Her blog aims to deliver thorough product reviews and useful tips, catering to readers interested in honest and effective guidance on a wide range of products. This platform serves as an extension of her passion for quality and transparency, mirroring the philosophy behind Two Days beverages.