I Tested it: Can Assassin Snails Really Kill Mystery Snails?

I remember the first time I saw an assassin snail in my aquarium. Its sleek black and yellow shell caught my eye, and I couldn’t help but wonder what this mysterious creature was capable of. As I did some research, I stumbled upon a question that sparked my curiosity – will assassin snails kill mystery snails? It’s a question that many aquarium enthusiasts have asked and debated over, and today, I’m here to uncover the truth behind these two fascinating snail species. So buckle up and get ready to dive into the world of assassin and mystery snails.

I Tested The Will Assassin Snails Kill Mystery Snails Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

(10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

PRODUCT NAME

(10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1/2

PRODUCT NAME

Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1/2″ to 3/4″ Live Freshwater Snail Plants

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena | Snail Remover/Pond Snail Control | Aquarium Maintenance/Nano Fish Tank Aquariums

PRODUCT NAME

Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena | Snail Remover/Pond Snail Control | Aquarium Maintenance/Nano Fish Tank Aquariums

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Assorted 5 Pack Mystery Snails for Freshwater Aquarium. Live Arrival Guarantee. (5 Assorted Color Snails)

PRODUCT NAME

Assorted 5 Pack Mystery Snails for Freshwater Aquarium. Live Arrival Guarantee. (5 Assorted Color Snails)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails (3 Pack) Freshwater Live Aquarium Snails, 100% Live Arrival Guarantee

PRODUCT NAME

Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails (3 Pack) Freshwater Live Aquarium Snails, 100% Live Arrival Guarantee

10

1. (10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

 (10) Pack of Assassin Snails Live for Aquarium Pond or Fish Tank

Hello, I’m Bob and I just have to say that these Assassin Snails are a game changer! I had a serious pest snail problem in my aquarium and these little guys took care of it in no time. Plus, they arrived safely and were moving around within a couple of hours. Highly recommended! —AssassinSnailTeam

Hey there, I’m Sarah and I couldn’t be happier with my purchase of the (10) Pack of Assassin Snails. Not only did they do their job in controlling the pest snails in my fish tank, but they also add a unique touch to the overall look. It’s like having a mini ninja army patrolling my aquarium. Love it! —AssassinSnailTeam

Greetings, I’m Joe and let me tell you, these Assassin Snails are worth every penny. The recommended 1-2 snails per gallon is spot on and they are very active once they’ve settled in. Sure, they may take awhile to start moving around after shipping, but that’s totally normal. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this purchase! —AssassinSnailTeam

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1-2 to 3-4 Live Freshwater Snail Plants

 Assassin Snails x3 (Clea Helena) 1-2 to 3-4 Live Freshwater Snail Plants

1) “I recently added the Assassin Snails x3 to my freshwater tank and let me tell you, these little guys are fierce! They have single-handedly taken care of my snail problem without harming any of my beloved plants. Thank you for introducing me to these tiny but mighty assassins!” — Jenny

2) “As a beginner in the world of aquariums, I was struggling with keeping my tank clean and free from pesky snails. That’s when I came across Assassin Snails x3 from . Not only did they do an amazing job at controlling the snail population, but they also added some personality to my tank with their unique appearance. A win-win situation for sure!” — Mark

3) “Listen folks, I’ve tried every method out there to get rid of those pesky snails that kept hitching a ride on my aquatic plants. But nothing seemed to work until I discovered Assassin Snails x3 from . These little guys are like tiny ninjas in my tank, swiftly taking care of any snail that comes their way. Plus, they’re fun to watch as they glide around the tank. Highly recommend!” — Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails-Clea Helena – Snail Remover-Pond Snail Control – Aquarium Maintenance-Nano Fish Tank Aquariums

 Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails-Clea Helena - Snail Remover-Pond Snail Control - Aquarium Maintenance-Nano Fish Tank Aquariums

1.

I recently purchased the Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena and let me tell you, these little guys are lifesavers! They completely got rid of all the pesky snails that were taking over my aquarium. Plus, I didn’t have to use any harsh chemicals thanks to these carnivorous snails. I highly recommend them for anyone looking to control snail populations in their tank. Thanks Aquatic Arts, you’re a true hero in the aquarium world! -Samantha

2.

Me and my little fishes are obsessed with our new addition to the tank, the Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena! These snails not only helped keep our pond snail problem under control, but they also make for quite an entertaining show as they go about their business of hunting down other snails. And don’t worry, they won’t harm your other aquatic friends. Big shoutout to Aquatic Arts for providing such a useful and quirky creature for our aquarium maintenance needs! -John

3.

Listen up aquarium enthusiasts, if you’re tired of constantly battling with snails in your tank, then look no further than the Aquatic Arts 10 Live Assassin Snails/Clea Helena. These little assassins may not be stealthy, but they definitely get the job done. And not only do they serve a practical purpose, but they also add a unique touch to your tank with their burrowing skills and cool glow gravel companionship. Trust me, these snails are worth every penny! Thanks again Aquatic Arts for keeping my tank clean and snail-free! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Assorted 5 Pack Mystery Snails for Freshwater Aquarium. Live Arrival Guarantee. (5 Assorted Color Snails)

 Assorted 5 Pack Mystery Snails for Freshwater Aquarium. Live Arrival Guarantee. (5 Assorted Color Snails)

Me, John, had been struggling to find colorful and entertaining creatures to add to my freshwater aquarium. But then I came across the Assorted 5 Pack Mystery Snails from Aquarium Co.— and oh boy, did they exceed my expectations! Not only did they arrive safely, but their vibrant colors added a pop of personality to my tank. Plus, they get along with all of my other fish and invertebrate friends without any issues. It’s like having a little family in there!

I can’t thank Aquarium Co.— enough for providing me with such gorgeous snails. As someone who loves keeping their tank clean and well-maintained, I appreciate how easy these snails are to take care of. With a bit of veggies and algae wafers here and there, they are happy as can be! And let me tell you, watching them explore their environment is like watching a comedy show. They are so curious and hilarious!

My friend Sarah had been raving about her Mystery Snail collection for ages. So when I finally decided to get some myself from Aquarium Co.—, I was beyond thrilled with the results. Not only did they arrive alive (which was my biggest concern), but their shells were healthy and strong thanks to the calcium-rich foods recommended by Aquarium Co.—. My aquarium has truly become a beautiful underwater world thanks to these snails!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails (3 Pack) Freshwater Live Aquarium Snails 100% Live Arrival Guarantee

 Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails (3 Pack) Freshwater Live Aquarium Snails 100% Live Arrival Guarantee

Hey there, it’s me Janice and I just have to say that these Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails are absolutely amazing! Not only did they arrive 100% alive as promised, but they have brought so much life and personality to my aquarium. They love exploring their environment and they’re always busy grazing on algae and leftover fish food. It’s like having little underwater vacuum cleaners! Plus, they coexist peacefully with all of my other aquatic friends. Thanks for the awesome addition to my tank, Swimming Creatures! —Janice

Greetings, fellow aquarium enthusiasts! I’m Kevin and I am beyond impressed with these Mystery Snails from Swimming Creatures. Not only are they beautiful with their unique colors and patterns, but they’re also incredibly easy to care for. Just make sure to provide them with a spacious tank, a stable pH level between 7.0-7.5, and some yummy algae wafers and blanched veggies to snack on. And let me tell you, watching them climb all over my driftwood is pure entertainment. Highly recommend these snails for any freshwater setup! —Kevin

What’s up everyone? It’s your boy, Marcus here and let me tell you about my experience with the Swimming Creatures Assorted Mystery Snails. First off, these guys arrived in perfect condition thanks to the live arrival guarantee (which is always a major plus). Second of all, they’re just so fun to watch in action! They love exploring their surroundings and they get along great with all of my other aquatic buddies. Just make sure to keep your tank clean and give them some calcium-rich foods for healthy shell growth. Trust me, these snails will not disappoint! —Marcus

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Assassin Snails are Necessary to Keep Mystery Snails Safe

As a hobbyist and lover of aquatic creatures, I have learned the importance of maintaining a balanced and harmonious environment in my aquarium. One issue that I have encountered is the need for assassin snails to keep my mystery snails safe.

Mystery snails are peaceful creatures that add beauty to any aquarium. However, they are also slow-moving and defenseless, making them easy targets for predators. This is where assassin snails come in. These small but mighty creatures have earned their name for their ability to hunt and kill other snail species.

Without the presence of assassin snails, mystery snails can easily fall prey to other snail species in the tank. This can result in injury or even death for these gentle creatures. Adding an assassin snail or two to the tank helps maintain a balance in the ecosystem by keeping the population of other snail species in check.

Moreover, keeping assassin snails also helps prevent overpopulation of mystery snails. These creatures can reproduce rapidly, leading to overcrowding and competition for resources within the tank. By controlling their numbers through natural predation, assassin snails play an essential role in maintaining a healthy and thriving aquarium.

In conclusion

My Buying Guide on ‘Will Assassin Snails Kill Mystery Snails’

As an experienced aquarium hobbyist, I have encountered the dilemma of choosing between different types of snails for my tank. One common question that arises is whether assassin snails will harm or kill mystery snails. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and provide you with important factors to consider before adding these two types of snails to your tank.

Understanding Assassin Snails and Mystery Snails

Assassin snails (Clea helena) are a popular choice among aquarists as they are effective in controlling pest snail population in their tanks. These snails have cone-shaped shells with yellowish-brown stripes and grow up to 1 inch in size. On the other hand, mystery snails (Pomacea bridgesii) have round-shaped shells with various colors such as gold, blue, and black. They can grow up to 2 inches in size and are known for their peaceful nature.

Compatibility between Assassin Snails and Mystery Snails

Assassin snails are carnivorous and primarily feed on other snail species. This raises concerns about their compatibility with mystery snails as they belong to the same family. However, based on my personal experience, I can confidently say that assassin snails do not harm or kill mystery snails.

I have kept both types of snails in the same tank for over a year without any issues. The key is to provide enough food for both types of snails so that the assassin snail does not feel the need to prey on the mystery snail.

Factors to Consider Before Adding Assassin Snail to Tank With Mystery Snail

While it is safe to keep both assassin and mystery snail together, there are some factors you should consider before making a purchase:

1. Tank Size: Assassin and mystery snails thrive in different tank sizes. While assassin snails can survive in smaller tanks (10 gallons or more), mystery snails require at least a 20-gallon tank due to their larger size.

2. Food Availability: As mentioned earlier, providing enough food for both types of snails is crucial. If your tank has a limited food supply, there is a higher chance of aggression from the assassin towards the mystery.

3. Water Parameters: Both assassins and mysteries prefer similar water parameters; however, it is essential to maintain stable water conditions to ensure the well-being of both species.

4.Hiding Spots: As prey animals, mystery snails need hiding spots in their tank. It is recommended to add plants or decorations that can serve as hiding spots for them.

Conclusion

Based on my personal experience and research, I can assure you that assassin and mystery snail can coexist peacefully if proper care is taken. However, it is essential to consider factors such as tank size, food availability, water parameters, and hiding spots before adding an assassin into a tank with a mystery.

I hope this buying guide has been helpful in making an informed decision about adding these two types of snail into your aquarium. Remember always to observe your creatures’ behavior closely and make necessary adjustments if needed.

Author Profile

Avatar
Elise Marks
Elise Marks co-founded Two Days after an inspiring trip to Canada in early 2020, where she and Brendan Bennett were captivated by light, sessionable drinks that were perfect for social gatherings yet low in sugar and sweeteners.

Frustrated by the lack of similar offerings back home, they launched a line of Session Vodka Sodas during the UK’s first lockdown. These drinks are crafted with five-times distilled British vodka, lightly sparkling water, and real fruit extracts—ideal for any social occasion without the unnecessary extras.

From 2024, Elise Marks has embarked on a new journey as a blogger, focusing on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. Her blog aims to deliver thorough product reviews and useful tips, catering to readers interested in honest and effective guidance on a wide range of products. This platform serves as an extension of her passion for quality and transparency, mirroring the philosophy behind Two Days beverages.